How JEPI and SPYI Earn Their Income, How Each Payment Is Taxed and What Each Fund Has Actually Returned
JEPI and SPYI are two of the largest covered-call ETFs that sell options on the S&P 500 to pay monthly income, but they are built and taxed very differently. JEPI, from J.P. Morgan, paid a 12-month rolling yield of 8.01% on 6 November 2026, and most of its income is taxed as ordinary income. SPYI, from NEOS, showed a 12-month distribution rate of 11.84% on 31 October 2026, and most of its payments have been classed as return of capital.
The returns differ as much as the yields. Over the three years to 30 September 2026, SPYI returned 17.68% a year at net asset value against 10.05% for JEPI and 22.89% for the S&P 500. JEPI charges 0.35% a year and SPYI 0.68%. This guide sets out where each fund's income comes from, how each payment is taxed, what each has returned and which kind of investor each design suits.
Know What You Own
The difference between investing and speculating isn't always obvious. Sometimes it comes down to the information you have, the risks you understand and the reasons behind your decision. Before committing your money, ask yourself whether you understand the investment well enough to explain how it works, how it generates returns and what could go wrong. If you don't, there is more to learn.
Choosing between JEPI and SPYI on the yield alone is exactly that kind of decision. One fund's payments arrive mostly as ordinary income, the other's mostly as return of capital, and the difference only shows up later, at tax time or when you sell. FRC's research-driven How to Invest in JEPI course takes you inside J.P. Morgan's fund so you can measure any rival against it, SPYI included. Built for income investors, ETF investors and finance graduates who need to know where JEPI's monthly income really comes from, it solves the problem of chasing a yield you don't understand, using J.P. Morgan's own SEC filings in plain English, with no qualifications required. The SIE, Series 7, Series 63 and Series 65 test ETFs at a general level; this course gives you the fund-level knowledge clients will actually ask you about. Follow the link, watch the short course video and decide for yourself whether it belongs in your plan before you choose between the two.
For how JEPI works as a whole, see FRC's complete guide to JEPI, the JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF.
JEPI vs SPYI at a Glance
| Fact | JEPI | SPYI | As Of |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full name | JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF | NEOS S&P 500 High Income ETF | — |
| Issuer | J.P. Morgan Asset Management | NEOS Investments | — |
| Launch date | 20 May 2020 | 29 Aug 2022 | — |
| Expense ratio | 0.35% | 0.68% | Nov 2026 |
| Net assets | $45.12 billion | $11.76 billion | 19 and 20 Nov 2026 |
| 12-month yield | 8.01% (rolling dividend yield) | 11.84% (trailing distribution rate) | 6 Nov / 31 Oct 2026 |
| 30-day SEC yield | 7.06% | 0.48% | 31 Oct 2026 |
| Payments | Monthly | Monthly | — |
| Latest payment | $0.34683 (ex-date 2 Nov 2026) | $0.5160 (ex-date 18 Nov 2026) | Nov 2026 |
| How options are sold | Out-of-the-money S&P 500 calls inside bank-issued notes, up to 20% of net assets | S&P 500 index (SPX) call options, sold and sometimes bought | Fund documents |
| Main tax label on payments | Ordinary income; 15.86% qualified (2025) | Return of capital; 93.91% (2024) | Latest full year published |
| 3-year return a year (NAV) | 10.05% | 17.68% | 30 Sep 2026 |
Sources: J.P. Morgan JEPI fund page and fund documents; NEOS SPYI fund page, fact sheet of 31 October 2026 and 2024 distribution classifications.
Which Number Are You Actually Buying?
If one fund shows an 11.84% yield and a 0.48% SEC yield on the same day, which number are you actually buying? That was SPYI on 31 October 2026, and both figures were correct.
Investors often compare JEPI's yield with another fund's yield without checking which figure each one is. A 12-month yield and a distribution rate are not the same measurement. Put JEPI's 8.01% next to SPYI's 11.84% and SPYI looks like the obvious choice; put their SEC yields side by side, 7.06% against 0.48%, and the picture reverses. Neither comparison tells you what you will keep, how your cost basis will change or what each fund has returned.
FRC's How to Invest in JEPI course gives you the yardstick for any covered-call fund: how the income is produced, what the options cost you in capped gains, how each payment is taxed and which account lets you keep the most. You finish with a written plan built around your own goal, and learners who pass the final examination receive an FRC Certificate of Completion. Price the course against the size of your investment, then decide.
To compare covered-call funds with confidence, ETF Investing for Beginners explains yields, fees and fund documents from the ground up. ETF Investing Strategies shows how an income fund fits a long-term plan, and Advanced ETF Investing goes into options-based funds and after-tax returns.
Tax is where JEPI and SPYI differ most, and FRC's 401(k) and ETF Taxes course shows you how each kind of payment is treated. Built for 401(k) and IRA savers, dividend and ETF investors and finance graduates who need to understand how retirement savings and investment income are taxed, it solves the problem of paying more tax than the law requires, using IRS publications and fund tax documents in plain English, with no qualifications or tax background required.
Return of Capital
Return of capital. Sounds like getting your own money back, doesn't it? Do you actually know what it means? It is a tax classification for a distribution that is not treated as income for the year, so it is not taxed when paid; instead it reduces your cost basis.
That makes it a deferral, not a gift. When you sell, the lower cost basis means a larger capital gain, and once your basis reaches zero, further return of capital is taxed as a capital gain. A return of capital label says how a payment is taxed, not whether the fund's value has fallen.
Section 1256 Contract
Section 1256 contract. Sounds like a clause buried in a legal document, doesn't it? Do you actually know what it means? It is a class of contracts, including broad-based index options such as SPX options, whose gains and losses are treated as 60% long-term and 40% short-term for tax, however long they were held.
SPYI uses SPX index options, which NEOS describes as Section 1256 contracts. JEPI earns its option income through notes issued by banks, and J.P. Morgan records the coupons as interest income, which is why the two funds' payments carry such different tax labels.
How Each Fund Earns Its Income
JEPI holds an actively managed portfolio of about 133 large US stocks chosen to swing less than the market. It earns most of its income by selling out-of-the-money call options on the S&P 500 through equity-linked notes issued by banks, which can make up as much as 20% of its net assets. J.P. Morgan's figures to 30 September 2026 put the since-launch rolling 12-month averages at about 7.14% from option premium and about 1.43% from stock dividends.
SPYI holds the companies of the S&P 500 and runs a call option strategy on the index itself. NEOS describes the overlay as data-driven and says it may include both sold and purchased SPX options, aiming for monthly income with some upside participation. Its fund managers may also harvest tax losses, and it gives up gains above the options' strike prices while still bearing the market's falls.
| Feature | JEPI | SPYI |
|---|---|---|
| Stock portfolio | About 133 stocks chosen for lower volatility | S&P 500 companies, close to index weights |
| Where options sit | Inside equity-linked notes issued by banks | Directly, as SPX index options |
| Option tax treatment at the fund | Note coupons recorded as interest income | Section 1256: 60% long-term, 40% short-term |
| Counterparty risk | Yes, on the bank-issued notes | Exchange-listed index options |
| Managed by | J.P. Morgan's U.S. Core Equity team, led by Hamilton Reiner | Garrett Paolella and Troy Cates, NEOS co-founders |
For how JEPI's notes work, see FRC's guide to how JEPI generates its monthly income.
Why J.P. Morgan Built JEPI This Way
JEPI was not invented from scratch. J.P. Morgan first ran the same strategy as a mutual fund, the JPMorgan Equity Premium Income Fund, whose institutional share class JEPIX launched on 31 August 2018 with a $1 million minimum investment and a 0.59% expense ratio. Hamilton Reiner and Raffaele Zingone have managed it since launch.
The ETF followed on 20 May 2020, two months after the Federal Reserve cut interest rates to near zero, when bonds paid almost nothing and market swings, which drive option premium, were high. JEPI opened at $50 a share with a 0.35% fee and no investment minimum beyond the price of a share, and the SEC's 2019 ETF rule, Rule 6c-11, had made launching ETFs of this kind simpler. Its Nasdaq-100 sister fund, JEPQ, followed in May 2022, a few months before SPYI.
The design reflects that start. A defensive stock portfolio aims to soften falls, while the bank-issued notes, limited to 20% of net assets, carry the option income. For the people behind it, see FRC's guide to who manages JEPI.
What Each Fund Owns
The two portfolios look very different at the top. SPYI's largest holdings mirror the S&P 500's, led by the biggest technology companies, while JEPI's are spread thinly across steadier names.
| SPYI's Top 3 (31 Oct 2026) | Weight | JEPI's Top 3 (6 Nov 2026) | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nvidia | 7.79% | Microsoft | 2.00% |
| Apple | 7.64% | Apple | 1.96% |
| Microsoft | 5.90% | Amazon | 1.90% |
SPYI's top 10 made up about 37.3% of the fund on 31 October 2026; JEPI's top 10 made up 19.03% on 6 November 2026. That one difference explains much of their behavior: SPYI rises and falls more like the S&P 500, while JEPI leans away from the largest technology stocks. JEPI is not equal-weighted, as some summaries claim; its stocks carry different weights chosen by its managers, with no holding above about 2% on 6 November 2026. For JEPI's full list, see FRC's guide to JEPI's holdings.
Why SPYI's SEC Yield Is So Low
The 30-day SEC yield counts only a fund's net investment income, such as dividends and interest, after expenses. It does not count capital gains, including gains on options.
SPYI's income comes mostly from its index options, which produce gains rather than interest, so very little of it shows up in the SEC yield: 0.48% against a distribution rate of 11.43% on 31 October 2026. JEPI's option income arrives as interest on its notes, so its SEC yield of 7.06% sits close to its 12-month yield of 8.01%. Neither figure is wrong; they measure different things, and the gap is a clue to how each fund's payments will be taxed.
| Yield Measure | JEPI | SPYI | What It Measures |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12-month yield | 8.01% (6 Nov 2026) | 11.84% (31 Oct 2026) | Payments over the past year divided by the price or NAV |
| Latest payment times 12 | About 7.38% (6 Nov 2026) | 11.43% (31 Oct 2026) | The latest monthly payment, annualized |
| 30-day SEC yield | 7.06% (31 Oct 2026) | 0.48% (31 Oct 2026) | Net investment income only, a standard formula |
For how JEPI's yield figures are worked out, see FRC's guide to why a high ETF dividend yield can be misleading.
What Each Fund Has Returned
Over the periods both funds share, SPYI has returned more. It has stayed closer to the S&P 500 because it holds the index's companies at close to their weights, while JEPI's defensive stock choices and notes have held it further back in a technology-led market.
| Average Annual Return to 30 Sep 2026 (NAV) | JEPI | SPYI | S&P 500 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 year | 6.62% | 14.62% | 15.74% |
| 3 years | 10.05% | 17.68% | 22.89% |
| SPYI since launch (29 Aug 2022) | n/a | 14.73% (75.34% cumulative) | 18.64% (101.13% cumulative) |
| JEPI since launch (20 May 2020) | 10.81% | n/a | 17.72% |
Sources: J.P. Morgan JEPI performance data; NEOS SPYI fact sheet. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
| $10,000 Over the 3 Years to 30 Sep 2026 | Ending Value | Gain |
|---|---|---|
| JEPI | About $13,330 | About $3,330 |
| SPYI | About $16,300 | About $6,300 |
| S&P 500 | About $18,560 | About $8,560 |
Calculated from each fund's 3-year annualized NAV return with distributions reinvested; hypothetical, before tax and trading costs.
Both funds trailed the S&P 500, as covered-call funds usually do in rising markets. NEOS's own benchmark comparison is the Cboe S&P 500 BuyWrite Index, which returned 14.78% a year over the same three years; SPYI beat it, while JEPI did not. For JEPI's side of that gap, see FRC's guide to why JEPI has underperformed the S&P 500.
What the Record Does Not Yet Show
SPYI's record began on 29 August 2022, after most of that year's bear market had already happened. JEPI's record includes all of 2022, when it returned −3.54% against −18.11% for the S&P 500, and its largest fall that year was about 13.7% including distributions.
Because SPYI holds the S&P 500's companies at close to index weights and keeps more of the market's exposure, it would be expected to fall further than JEPI in a broad sell-off. Its record does not yet include a full calendar-year bear market to confirm how far, which is worth remembering when comparing three years of strong markets.
How Steady Each Fund's Payments Have Been
JEPI's monthly payments move with option premium, which rises in stormy markets and shrinks in calm ones. In 2026 they ranged from $0.34134 to $0.44761 a share, a difference of about 31%, and its yearly total fell about 33.7% from 2022 to 2024.
SPYI's payments have moved in a narrower band in the months covered by NEOS's documents: $0.5423 a share in August 2026, $0.5087 in October and $0.5160 in November. NEOS's notice for the August payment estimated just $0.0186 of the $0.5423 as net investment income and the other 97% as return of capital, so the size of the payment is not a measure of the income the fund earned that month.
| Recent Monthly Payment | JEPI | SPYI |
|---|---|---|
| Latest | $0.34683 (ex-date 2 Nov 2026) | $0.5160 (ex-date 18 Nov 2026) |
| 2026 range or recent examples | $0.34134 to $0.44761 | $0.5423 (Aug), $0.5087 (Oct), $0.5160 (Nov) |
| Main label on the payment | Mostly ordinary income | Mostly return of capital, which lowers your cost basis |
A steadier payment is easier to budget around, but it does not mean the fund earned that amount in income. For JEPI's full payment record, see FRC's JEPI dividend history.
How Each Fund's Payments Are Taxed
This is the biggest practical difference between the two funds. JEPI's payments are mostly ordinary income, taxed in the year you receive them. SPYI's have mostly been classed as return of capital, which is not taxed when paid but lowers your cost basis.
| Tax Point | JEPI | SPYI |
|---|---|---|
| Latest full-year classification | Tax year 2025: 15.86% qualified dividends, the rest ordinary income | 2024: 93.91% return of capital, 6.09% ordinary dividends |
| Return of capital | None in fiscal years 2021 to 2026, per annual reports | Most of each payment in 2024; NEOS estimated 98% for its December 2025 payment |
| 2026 estimates | Final split reported on Form 1099-DIV | NEOS's 19 August 2026 notice estimated 96% of fiscal-year-to-date payments as return of capital |
| Effect on cost basis | None | Basis falls by the return of capital each year |
| When the tax arrives | Every year, on the payments | Mostly when you sell, as a capital gain |
NEOS's monthly Section 19(a) notices are estimates on a book basis and are not for tax reporting; the final split each year appears on Form 1099-DIV and can differ. JEPI's 2025 figure comes from J.P. Morgan's published tax information. For JEPI's full tax rules, see FRC's guide to how JEPI is taxed.
What $10,000 Keeps in Its First Year
The table below is a hypothetical illustration for a single filer in the 24% federal bracket, holding $10,000 of each fund in a taxable account for one year. It uses each fund's 12-month yield and its latest full-year tax split.
| Hypothetical, Taxable Account, 24% Bracket | JEPI | SPYI |
|---|---|---|
| Income received on $10,000 | About $801 (8.01%) | About $1,184 (11.84%) |
| Taxed now | About $181 (ordinary income at 24%, qualified part at 15%) | About $17 (the 6.09% ordinary part at 24%) |
| Kept this year | About $620 | About $1,167 |
| Cost basis reduced by | $0 | About $1,112 |
SPYI's lower tax bill this year is a deferral, not a saving. The $1,112 of return of capital lowers the cost basis, so when the shares are sold the capital gain is larger by that amount, usually taxed at long-term rates if held more than a year. An investor who never sells, or whose shares pass to an heir, may never pay that deferred tax, while an investor who sells within a year may pay at short-term rates.
State tax comes on top in a taxable account. New York taxes ordinary income at up to 10.9%, plus up to 3.876% for New York City residents, and gives long-term gains no lower rate. North Carolina taxes both at a flat 3.99% for 2026, falling to 3.49% for 2027. FRC's guide to how your 401(k) and ETFs are taxed shows how the same fund is taxed in a brokerage account, a traditional 401(k) and a Roth.
Inside an IRA or 401(k)
Inside a traditional IRA, Roth IRA or 401(k), the tax labels on the payments do not matter while the money stays in the account. Ordinary income and return of capital are treated the same, so the comparison comes down to returns, risk and cost.
That changes the answer for many investors. SPYI's tax advantage over JEPI is largest in a taxable account, and disappears inside a tax-advantaged one.
What Each Fund Costs
JEPI charges 0.35% a year and SPYI 0.68%. On $10,000, that is about $35 a year for JEPI and about $68 for SPYI; on $100,000, about $350 against $680.
| Holding | JEPI at 0.35% | SPYI at 0.68% | Difference a Year |
|---|---|---|---|
| $10,000 | About $35 | About $68 | About $33 |
| $50,000 | About $175 | About $340 | About $165 |
| $100,000 | About $350 | About $680 | About $330 |
Fees are taken from each fund's assets and are already reflected in the returns above. For what JEPI's fee pays for, see FRC's guide to JEPI's expense ratio.
Which Fund Suits Which Investor
These are hypothetical illustrations of the trade-offs, not recommendations.
| Investor (Hypothetical) | Leans Towards | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| Wants steadier swings and a long record including 2022 | JEPI | Defensive stock portfolio; record includes a full bear market |
| Holds income funds in a taxable account and wants to defer tax | SPYI | Most payments classed as return of capital, taxed mainly on sale |
| Holds income funds inside an IRA or 401(k) | Either, on returns and cost | Tax labels do not matter inside the account |
| Wants more of the S&P 500's upside with monthly income | SPYI | Holds the index's companies at close to their weights |
| Wants the lowest fee | JEPI | 0.35% against 0.68% |
| Already owns a large S&P 500 fund | JEPI | SPYI's top holdings largely repeat the index |
Whichever fund you choose, the yield should not decide it on its own. For the wider set of covered-call designs, see FRC's guide to covered-call ETFs and how JEPI, JEPQ and SPYI generate income.
Common Mistakes When Choosing Between JEPI and SPYI
| Mistake | The Correction |
|---|---|
| Picking SPYI because 11.84% is higher than 8.01% | Compare total return, tax and cost, not the headline yield |
| Comparing JEPI's SEC yield with SPYI's distribution rate | SPYI's SEC yield was 0.48%; each figure measures something different |
| Treating return of capital as tax-free income | It lowers your cost basis, so the tax arrives when you sell |
| Assuming return of capital means the fund is shrinking | It is a tax label; check the NAV and total return to judge the fund |
| Using NEOS's monthly 19(a) estimates for your tax return | They are book-basis estimates; use the final Form 1099-DIV |
| Holding SPYI in an IRA for its tax treatment | The labels do not matter inside the account |
| Assuming SPYI will fall as little as JEPI in a bear market | SPYI holds the index at close to its weights; its record has no full bear-market year |
| Owning SPYI and a large S&P 500 fund as if they were different bets | Their largest holdings are largely the same |
| Believing JEPI is equal-weighted | Its managers set each stock's weight; no holding was above about 2% on 6 November 2026 |
| Reading SPYI's steady payment as income earned | NEOS estimated 97% of the August 2026 payment as return of capital |
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, JEPI or SPYI?
Neither is better for everyone. SPYI returned 17.68% a year over the three years to 30 September 2026 against 10.05% for JEPI and has mostly paid return of capital, while JEPI costs about half as much at 0.35%, holds a more defensive portfolio and has a record that includes the full 2022 bear market.
Why does SPYI pay more than JEPI?
SPYI's 12-month distribution rate was 11.84% on 31 October 2026, against JEPI's 8.01% 12-month yield on 6 November 2026. SPYI sells index options across a portfolio that holds the S&P 500's companies, while JEPI sells options through notes on up to 20% of its assets and holds a lower-volatility stock portfolio.
Why is SPYI's SEC yield only 0.48%?
Because the SEC yield counts only net investment income, such as dividends and interest. SPYI's option income comes mostly as gains on index options, which the formula excludes, while JEPI's note coupons are recorded as interest and are included.
Is SPYI's income tax-free?
No. Most of SPYI's 2024 payments, 93.91%, were classed as return of capital, which is not taxed when paid but lowers your cost basis, so the tax arrives as a larger capital gain when you sell. The final split each year is reported on Form 1099-DIV.
How is JEPI taxed compared with SPYI?
JEPI's payments are mostly ordinary income, taxed in the year received; for tax year 2025, 15.86% were qualified dividends. JEPI's annual reports show no return of capital from fiscal 2021 to 2026.
Is SPYI riskier than JEPI?
It holds more of the market's risk. SPYI's portfolio follows the S&P 500's companies at close to their weights, with its top 10 at about 37.3% of the fund on 31 October 2026, against 19.03% for JEPI's top 10. SPYI's record also began in August 2022, so it does not yet include a full bear-market year.
What are the expense ratios of JEPI and SPYI?
JEPI charges 0.35% a year and SPYI 0.68%, or about $35 and $68 a year on every $10,000.
Do JEPI and SPYI both pay monthly?
Yes. JEPI's latest payment was $0.34683 a share for the 2 November 2026 ex-date, and SPYI's was $0.5160 a share for the 18 November 2026 ex-date.
Should I hold JEPI or SPYI in a Roth IRA?
Inside a Roth IRA, the tax labels on the payments do not matter, so SPYI's return of capital advantage disappears. The choice comes down to returns, risk, cost and how each fund fits the rest of your portfolio.
Is SPYI a covered-call ETF?
It is an option-income fund in the same family. SPYI holds S&P 500 companies and runs a call option strategy on the S&P 500 index, which NEOS says may include both sold and purchased SPX options, so part of the upside can be kept rather than all of it sold away.
How does SPYI make its payments more tax-efficient?
Through three features NEOS describes: SPX index options taxed as Section 1256 contracts at 60% long-term and 40% short-term, tax-loss harvesting by its managers, and payments that have mostly been classed as return of capital, which defers tax until you sell.
How long has JEPI's strategy existed?
Since 31 August 2018, when J.P. Morgan launched it as a mutual fund, the JPMorgan Equity Premium Income Fund. The ETF version, JEPI, followed on 20 May 2020 with a 0.35% fee, against 0.59% for the mutual fund's institutional class.
Can I own both JEPI and SPYI?
You can, but both sell call options linked to the S&P 500, so owning both means capping part of your upside twice. Check how much of each you hold and what your other funds already own before combining them.
Same Goal, Different Engines
JEPI and SPYI both turn the S&P 500 into monthly income, but they use different engines and leave investors with different results. SPYI has returned more, paid more and passed most of its payments through as return of capital; JEPI costs about half as much, holds a steadier portfolio, pays income taxed as it arrives and has been tested through a full bear market.
The right choice depends on your account, your tax bracket and how much of the market's swings you want to carry, not on the headline yield. FRC's How to Invest in JEPI course gives you the facts behind J.P. Morgan's fund and the yardstick to judge any rival against it. Get started today, with interest-free payment plans available.
This article is general education, not investment or tax advice. Figures are taken from J.P. Morgan's and NEOS's fund documents and were correct at the dates shown. Past performance does not guarantee future results, and distributions vary from month to month and are not guaranteed.

