How Far JEPI Has Trailed the S&P 500, the Four Reasons Why and When It Has Come Out Ahead
JEPI has underperformed the S&P 500 because it was built to. The fund sells call options that give away part of the market’s gains, and its stock portfolio leans towards steadier companies that rise less in strong markets. From launch on 20 May 2020 to 30 September 2026, JEPI returned 10.81% a year at NAV against 17.72% for the S&P 500.
That gap has been widest in fast rallies led by a few large technology companies, as in 2023. JEPI has also done what it was designed to do: it paid high monthly income, swung far less than the market and lost far less in 2022. Whether the underperformance matters depends on what you bought it for.
Know What You Own
Don’t follow the crowd. Don’t rely on a ticker name or headline alone. Know what your ETFs own, how they work, how they generate income, what risks they carry and what the terminology really means. Ask better questions, understand the details and take greater control of your financial future. Don’t just invest. Understand your investment.
FRC’s How to Invest in JEPI course shows you exactly where JEPI’s gap to the market comes from, using J.P. Morgan’s own SEC filings, so you can judge the fund on facts rather than headlines.
JEPI vs the S&P 500 at a Glance
| Measure | JEPI | S&P 500 | As Of |
|---|---|---|---|
| Return since launch (a year) | 10.81% | 17.72% | 30 Sep 2026 |
| $10,000 at launch grew to | About $19,215 | About $28,236 | 30 Sep 2026 |
| Full years JEPI trailed (2021 to 2025) | 4 of 5 | — | 31 Dec 2025 |
| Return in 2022 | −3.54% | −18.11% | 31 Dec 2022 |
| 3-year beta | 0.42 | 1.00 | 30 Sep 2026 |
| 3-year standard deviation | 7.78 | 12.42 | 30 Sep 2026 |
For how the whole fund works, see FRC’s complete guide to JEPI, the JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF.
How Far JEPI Has Trailed, Year by Year
The table uses calendar-year total returns at NAV from J.P. Morgan’s fact sheet, with distributions reinvested and after the fund’s fee. JEPI’s benchmark is the S&P 500 Total Return Index, which also includes reinvested dividends, so the comparison is like for like.
| Year | JEPI | S&P 500 | Difference | JEPI’s Return as a Share of the Index’s |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2021 | 21.61% | 28.71% | −7.10 points | About 75% |
| 2022 | −3.54% | −18.11% | +14.57 points | About 20% of the loss |
| 2023 | 9.88% | 26.29% | −16.41 points | About 38% |
| 2024 | 12.56% | 25.02% | −12.46 points | About 50% |
| 2025 | 8.07% | 17.88% | −9.81 points | About 45% |
| 2026 (to 30 Sep) | 3.65% | 12.75% | −9.10 points | About 29% |
JEPI trailed in every year the market rose and led by a wide margin in the one year it fell. That pattern is the clearest sign that the gap comes from the fund’s design rather than from one bad decision. For the full record, see FRC’s guide to JEPI’s performance history.
Over longer periods the share of the market’s return JEPI kept has varied, as the table below shows for the periods to 30 September 2026.
| Period to 30 Sep 2026 | JEPI at NAV (a year) | S&P 500 (a year) | Share JEPI Kept |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 year | 6.62% | 15.74% | About 42% |
| 3 years | 10.05% | 22.89% | About 44% |
| 5 years | 7.78% | 13.79% | About 56% |
| Since launch | 10.81% | 17.72% | About 61% |
The five-year and since-launch figures look better because they include 2022, when JEPI’s smaller loss narrowed the gap. The three-year figure, which covers an almost unbroken rally, shows how far JEPI can fall behind when markets climb steadily.
JEPI’s Total Return vs the S&P 500 in Dollars
Yearly rates can hide how large the gap becomes over time. The table turns the same J.P. Morgan figures into cumulative total returns on $10,000, with distributions reinvested.
| Period to 30 Sep 2026 | JEPI Cumulative | $10,000 in JEPI | S&P 500 Cumulative | $10,000 in the S&P 500 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 year | About 6.6% | About $10,662 | About 15.7% | About $11,574 |
| 3 years | About 33.3% | About $13,328 | About 85.6% | About $18,559 |
| 5 years | About 45.4% | About $14,544 | About 90.8% | About $19,077 |
| Since launch (20 May 2020) | About 92.2% | About $19,215 | About 182.4% | About $28,236 |
Over five years, JEPI roughly kept half of the market’s cumulative gain. There is no 10-year record yet, because the fund only launched in May 2020.
Reason 1: The Call Options Cap the Gains
JEPI earns most of its income by selling call options on the S&P 500. A call option gives the buyer the right to the index’s gains above a set level, called the strike price, for a fixed period. In return, the buyer pays the fund a premium, and that premium is the main source of JEPI’s monthly income.
JEPI sells these calls through equity-linked notes issued by banks, which can make up as much as 20% of the fund’s net assets and were about 13.7% on 30 June 2026. J.P. Morgan sells calls with strikes above the index’s current level, known as out-of-the-money calls, and renews them roughly every month.
Upside participation. Sounds technical, doesn’t it? Do you actually know what it means? It is simply how much of a rally your fund actually keeps. For a covered-call fund like JEPI, upside participation is limited by design, because every month part of the gain above the strike belongs to someone else.
Here is how the cap works in round numbers. The figures are hypothetical and simplified, and they ignore JEPI’s stock portfolio.
| Index Move in the Month | Plain Index Holder | Covered-Call Position (Strike $102, Premium $1) |
|---|---|---|
| Falls from $100 to $94 | −$6 | −$5 (the $1 premium softens the fall) |
| Rises from $100 to $101 | +$1 | +$2 (the $1 gain plus the $1 premium) |
| Rises from $100 to $106 | +$6 | +$3 (gains stop at $102, plus the $1 premium) |
In a quiet month, the premium adds to the return. In a strong month, the gains above the strike go to the call buyer. When the market rises strongly month after month, as it did through 2023 and 2024, those capped months add up to a large gap.
Reason 2: A Defensive Stock Portfolio
The options are only part of the story. JEPI’s stocks are chosen by J.P. Morgan’s research team to swing less than the market, and the portfolio holds about 133 positions rather than the 500 companies in the S&P 500.
The S&P 500 weights each company by its total market value, so its largest companies have the biggest effect on its return. JEPI deliberately keeps each holding small. The table compares the largest positions.
| Company | Weight in the S&P 500 (via SPY, 30 Sep 2026) | Weight in JEPI |
|---|---|---|
| NVIDIA | 8.38% | 1.52% (30 Jun 2026) |
| Apple | 7.37% | 1.96% (6 Nov 2026) |
| Microsoft | 5.77% | 2.00% (6 Nov 2026) |
| Amazon | 3.71% | 1.90% (6 Nov 2026) |
| Top 10 combined | 39.04% | 15.85% (30 Jun 2026) |
Information Technology made up about 39.71% of the S&P 500 via SPY on 30 September 2026, against about 17.8% of JEPI’s stock portfolio on 30 June 2026. JEPI spreads that difference across industrials, health care, consumer staples and utilities.
On a $10,000 holding, an S&P 500 fund would have held about $838 in NVIDIA at those weights, while JEPI held about $152. When the market’s largest technology companies surge, the index gains far more from them.
2023 showed the effect clearly. According to the index provider’s year-end review, seven very large technology-related companies (Apple, Microsoft, Alphabet, Amazon, NVIDIA, Meta and Tesla) produced about 62% of the S&P 500’s total return that year, and the rest of the index returned about 9.9%. JEPI returned 9.88%, almost exactly what the market did without those seven. For what the fund holds now, see FRC’s guide to JEPI’s holdings.
Do You Know Why Your Fund Trailed the Market?
If your fund trailed the market by about $9,000 on every $10,000, would you know why?
Many buyers can’t explain why JEPI trailed the S&P 500 in 2021, 2023, 2024 and 2025. That explanation should come before the money, not after. Investors who don’t know where the gap comes from tend to make one of two costly mistakes: they sell JEPI after a strong rally, just before the kind of market where it holds up best, or they hold it expecting market-beating growth it was never built to deliver.
FRC’s How to Invest in JEPI course takes you through every cause of the gap from J.P. Morgan’s prospectus, annual reports and fact sheets: how the notes cap the gains, how the stock portfolio differs from the index, why the income shrinks in calm markets and how JEPI behaved in the 2022 bear market and the 2025 sell-off. You’ll be able to judge JEPI against its real aim, decide whether its trade-off fits your goals and finish with a written JEPI plan. Learners who pass the final examination receive an FRC Certificate of Completion. Spend a little to learn before you spend a lot to find out.
If you want to understand performance across every fund you own, ETF Investing for Beginners shows you how to compare any ETF with its benchmark fairly. ETF Investing Strategies shows you how growth funds and income funds can work together, and Advanced ETF Investing takes you into options-based funds and why they behave the way they do.
Reason 3: Calmer Markets Mean Smaller Premiums
Option premiums tend to be larger when markets expect bigger swings and smaller when markets are calm. In a steady rally, JEPI collects less income from its calls at the same time as the calls cap its gains.
That is what happened after 2022. JEPI’s payments shrank as markets calmed, so the income part of its return was smaller just when the index was climbing fastest.
| Ex-Date Year | JEPI Distributions per Share | Change on the Year Before |
|---|---|---|
| 2022 (bear market) | $6.36214 | +52.9% |
| 2023 (rally) | $4.61827 | −27.4% |
| 2024 (rally) | $4.21640 | −8.7% |
| 2025 (sell-off and rebound) | $4.71996 | +11.9% |
An investor holding 1,000 shares received about $6,362 in 2022 and about $4,216 in 2024, a fall of about 33.7% from exactly the same shares. In 2026, with markets calmer again, JEPI’s monthly payments to November ranged from $0.34134 to $0.44761 a share, the steadiest run in its record but well below its 2022 peak. For how the income is produced, see FRC’s guide to how JEPI generates its monthly income.
Reason 4: Fast Rebounds Leave JEPI Behind
A covered-call fund tends to fall behind when the market recovers quickly after a drop. After a fall, new calls are written with strikes close to the lower index level, so a sharp bounce runs straight into the cap.
As a hypothetical, suppose the index falls from $100 to $85. The fund then sells a new one-month call with a strike of $87 and collects a $1 premium. If the index jumps back to $95 that month, a plain index holder gains $10, while the covered-call position gains only $3: $2 up to the strike plus the $1 premium.
Early 2025 showed this in real markets. The S&P 500 fell about 18.9% on a price basis from 19 February to 8 April 2025, while JEPI fell about 13.3% on a total-return basis. The index then recovered quickly, reaching a new record close on 27 June 2025. JEPI lagged the rebound and finished 2025 up 8.07% against 17.88% for the S&P 500.
The cushion in 2025 was also smaller than in 2022. JEPI took about 70% of the market’s fall in 2025, against about 54% in 2022, because the 2025 drop was fast and left little time for monthly premiums to build up. For how deep JEPI’s falls have been, see FRC’s guide to whether JEPI is safe.
In Flat or Choppy Markets, the Gap Can Close
The options do not only cost JEPI in rallies. When the market moves sideways, rising a little one month and falling a little the next, the cap is rarely reached and the premium is kept, so a covered-call position can do better than the index.
| Hypothetical Month | Plain Index Holder | Covered-Call Position (New Call Each Month, Strike $2 Above, Premium $1) |
|---|---|---|
| Index rises from $100 to $101 | +$1 | +$2 |
| Index falls from $101 to $100 | −$1 | About $0 (the new $1 premium offsets the fall) |
| Two months combined | About $0 | About +$2 |
These figures are simplified and ignore JEPI’s stock portfolio, fees and taxes. JEPI’s full record does not yet include a long flat market, so this pattern is the design at work rather than a measured result. Since launch, the strong rallies have far outweighed the quiet stretches.
Is the Fee to Blame?
No. JEPI’s expense ratio is 0.35% a year, and the gap to the S&P 500 since launch has been about 6.9 percentage points a year. The fee explains only about one-twentieth of it.
| Part of the Gap | Size |
|---|---|
| Yearly gap to the S&P 500, launch to 30 Sep 2026 | About 6.91 points |
| JEPI’s expense ratio | 0.35 points |
| Share of the gap explained by the fee | About 5% |
| The rest | Capped gains, defensive stocks and timing of premiums |
An S&P 500 index fund such as VOO charges 0.03%, so the fee difference is about 0.32 points a year. That is real money over time, but it is not why JEPI trailed by thousands of dollars. For the full breakdown of the fee, see FRC’s guide to the JEPI expense ratio.
Underperforming, or Doing Its Job?
JEPI’s prospectus objective is to seek current income while maintaining prospects for capital appreciation. Its aim is income and lower volatility, not to beat or match the S&P 500. The prospectus also warns that the fund may underperform its benchmark, particularly in rising markets.
Judged against that aim, the record looks different. JEPI’s risk figures for the three years to 30 September 2026 show what the lower return bought.
| Measure (3 Years to 30 Sep 2026) | JEPI | S&P 500 | What It Means |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standard deviation | 7.78 | 12.42 | JEPI’s returns swung about 37% less |
| Beta | 0.42 | 1.00 | JEPI tended to move a little under half as much as the index |
| Sharpe ratio | 0.73 | 1.36 | The index still earned more return for each unit of swing |
The Sharpe ratio is the honest part of this table. Over these three years, the S&P 500 rewarded its extra risk handsomely, so JEPI’s smoother ride came at a price. In a period with deeper or longer falls, that comparison could look very different.
A simple FRC calculation from the calendar-year figures shows the trade in one line. In the up years 2021 and 2023 to 2025, JEPI averaged about 13.03% a year against about 24.48% for the index, so it kept about 53% of the gains. In 2022, it took about 20% of the index’s loss. J.P. Morgan does not publish official capture ratios for JEPI, so treat these as a rough guide.
When JEPI Has Come Out Ahead
The one full year JEPI beat the S&P 500 was 2022. The index fell 18.11% while JEPI fell 3.54%, a lead of 14.57 percentage points. Its income also rose that year, to $6.36214 a share.
The growth-of-$10,000 figures show how that single year changed the race.
| Date | JEPI | S&P 500 | Ahead |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20 May 2020 (launch) | $10,000 | $10,000 | Level |
| 31 Dec 2021 | $14,379 | $16,431 | S&P 500 |
| 31 Dec 2022 | $13,870 | $13,455 | JEPI |
| 31 Dec 2023 | $15,240 | $16,993 | S&P 500 |
| 31 Dec 2024 | $17,154 | $21,245 | S&P 500 |
| 31 Dec 2025 | $18,539 | $25,043 | S&P 500 |
| 30 Sep 2026 | $19,215 | $28,236 | S&P 500 |
At the end of 2022, JEPI was briefly ahead since launch. The rally that followed then carried the index well clear. A smaller loss in a bad year does not guarantee a lead over a full cycle, and the size of the next fall, and how quickly the market recovers, will decide how the race looks in future.
A smaller monthly fall is not guaranteed either. In September 2026, JEPI returned −1.62% at NAV while the S&P 500 returned −0.35%. Lower beta describes an average, not a promise for every month.
What JEPI’s Underperformance Means for You
Whether JEPI’s lag is a problem depends on why you hold it. The table sets out how the same record reads to different investors.
| If Your Goal Is | How to Read JEPI’s Record |
|---|---|
| Maximum long-term growth | The lag has been costly; an S&P 500 fund has done more |
| High monthly income | JEPI delivered it, though the amount has varied widely |
| A smoother ride | JEPI swung far less, but still fell about 13% twice |
| Replacing cash | JEPI beat 3-month Treasury bills by about 7.89 points a year since launch, but cash carried almost no risk of loss |
| Replacing bonds | JEPI’s price moves with stocks, so it carries far more stock-market risk than bonds |
Some investors hold JEPI alongside an S&P 500 fund such as VOO, so the index fund carries the growth and JEPI provides income. Others prefer JEPI’s Nasdaq-100 sister fund, JEPQ, which uses the same approach on a more technology-heavy index and so behaves differently in tech-led rallies.
Investors who need to spend the income should also check that JEPI’s price has held up while it paid. Its NAV was $56.38 on 6 November 2026, about 12.8% above its $50.00 launch level. For the full picture, see FRC’s guide to whether JEPI loses value over time.
Will JEPI Keep Underperforming?
No one can know. Based on how the fund is built, JEPI is likely to trail the S&P 500 in strong, steady rallies, especially ones led by a handful of very large technology companies. It is likely to hold up better in long, slow falls, as it did in 2022.
Several things could change the size of the gap: how volatile markets are, how concentrated the S&P 500’s gains become, how J.P. Morgan sets the strikes on its notes and how the stock portfolio changes. J.P. Morgan does not disclose how far above the index it sets each strike, so the size of the cap cannot be measured from the outside. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
Common Mistakes When Comparing JEPI With the S&P 500
| Mistake | The Correction |
|---|---|
| Comparing JEPI’s total return with the S&P 500’s price return | Use the total-return index, which includes dividends, as J.P. Morgan does |
| Judging JEPI on one year | It trailed in four rising years and led in the one falling year |
| Blaming the fee | 0.35% explains only about 5% of the yearly gap since launch |
| Assuming the managers are failing | The prospectus warns the fund may lag in rising markets |
| Selling after a rally | That is when the gap looks worst and a falling market may come next |
| Expecting the same cushion in every fall | JEPI took about 54% of the 2022 fall and about 70% of the 2025 fall |
| Adding the yield to the index return | JEPI’s yield is part of its total return, not extra on top of the market’s |
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is JEPI doing so poorly?
JEPI is not doing poorly against its own aim. It has paid high monthly income and swung far less than the market. It looks poor next to the S&P 500 because it sells call options that cap part of the gains and holds a defensive portfolio, and the market has risen strongly in most years since its launch.
Why has JEPI underperformed the S&P 500?
JEPI sells call options that cap part of the market’s gains, and it holds a defensive portfolio with small weights in the largest technology companies. In calm, rising markets, its option income also shrinks. Together these held JEPI to 10.81% a year since launch against 17.72% for the S&P 500, to 30 September 2026.
How much has JEPI underperformed the S&P 500?
From launch to 30 September 2026, about 6.91 percentage points a year at NAV. $10,000 put into JEPI at launch grew to about $19,215, against about $28,236 in the S&P 500.
Has JEPI ever beaten the S&P 500?
Yes, in 2022. JEPI returned −3.54% while the S&P 500 returned −18.11%. It has trailed in every other full calendar year since 2021.
Is JEPI supposed to beat the S&P 500?
No. Its objective is current income while maintaining prospects for capital appreciation, with lower volatility than the market. The prospectus says it may underperform its benchmark, particularly in rising markets.
Is JEPI’s fee the reason it underperforms?
No. The 0.35% fee explains only about 5% of the yearly gap since launch. Most of the gap comes from the capped gains and the defensive stock mix.
Why did JEPI do so badly in 2023?
The S&P 500 returned 26.29%, with seven very large technology-related companies producing about 62% of that return. JEPI held those companies at small weights, its calls capped part of the rally and its premiums shrank as markets calmed. It returned 9.88%.
How does JEPI perform in a down market?
It has lost less than the S&P 500 in falls so far: about 13.7% against about 25.4% in 2022, and about 13.3% against about 18.9% in early 2025. It still lost money, and it lagged the rebound that followed.
Should I sell JEPI because it underperforms?
That depends on your goals, not on the gap alone. An investor who wants maximum growth may prefer an index fund, while one who wants monthly income and smaller swings may accept the lag. FRC can’t tell you what to do with your own money, so weigh it against your plan. For a full assessment, see FRC’s guide to whether JEPI is a good investment.
What is JEPI’s 5-year return?
For the five years to 30 September 2026, JEPI returned 7.78% a year at NAV, about 45.4% in total, against 13.79% a year, about 90.8% in total, for the S&P 500. JEPI has no 10-year record yet, because it launched in May 2020.
Is now a good time to buy JEPI?
No one can time the market reliably, and FRC doesn’t give buy or sell recommendations. Based on its design, JEPI has tended to trail in strong rallies and hold up better in falls, so the right time depends on whether you want its income and smaller swings rather than on a market forecast.
Is JEPI better than VOO?
Neither is better for everyone. VOO tracks the S&P 500 for 0.03% a year and has grown far more since JEPI’s launch, while JEPI pays high monthly income and has swung less. They do different jobs.
The Gap Is the Trade
JEPI has underperformed the S&P 500 because every month it trades part of the market’s growth for income and a smoother ride. In strong rallies that trade is expensive, and in long falls it has paid off. Neither outcome means the fund is broken; both are what its design predicts.
The question is whether you want that trade. FRC’s How to Invest in JEPI course shows you each part of it from J.P. Morgan’s own documents and gives you a written plan to decide whether JEPI belongs in your portfolio. The course costs less than the difference one informed decision can make.
This article is general education, not investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results, and distributions vary from month to month and are not guaranteed.

