A Tax-Free Swap of Insurance Contracts

A 1035 exchange is a transfer of one life insurance policy, endowment contract or annuity into another without paying tax on the gain built up inside the old contract. It takes its name from Section 1035 of the Internal Revenue Code, and the cost basis of the old contract carries over into the new one, so the tax is deferred rather than eliminated.

Only certain swaps qualify. A life insurance policy can be exchanged for another life policy, an endowment, an annuity or a qualified long-term care contract, and an annuity can be exchanged for another annuity or a qualified long-term care contract. An annuity cannot be exchanged tax-free for a life insurance policy.

The exchange must generally keep the same owner and insured or annuitant, and the money should move directly between insurers rather than passing through the owner’s hands. For the full route from the exam to a career in advice, our complete guide to how to become an investment adviser representative covers every step.

Pass in Q1: work through the FRC video playlists one topic at a time

Why the 1035 Exchange Exists

Life insurance and annuities grow tax-deferred, so a contract held for many years can contain a large untaxed gain. Without Section 1035, surrendering an old contract to buy a better one would trigger tax on that gain immediately.

The rule lets policy owners move to a contract with lower fees, better features, a stronger insurer or a guarantee that suits their current needs, without being locked into an outdated product by the tax bill. The deferral continues inside the new contract.

That flexibility makes the 1035 exchange a common planning tool and a common source of abuse, which is why it is closely regulated. The Series 65 Exam Preparation course at FRC covers 1035 exchanges alongside annuity taxation, insurance products and the suitability rules that govern replacements.

Which Exchanges Qualify

The direction of the exchange matters. The rule allows a move toward a contract that defers tax for the same or longer, but not toward one that would shelter income in a new way.

A life insurance policy can be exchanged for another life policy, an endowment contract, an annuity or a qualified long-term care policy. An endowment can be exchanged for another endowment that matures no later, an annuity or a qualified long-term care policy. An annuity can be exchanged for another annuity or a qualified long-term care policy.

The prohibited direction is from an annuity to life insurance. Life insurance offers an income-tax-free death benefit, so allowing an annuity’s untaxed gain to move into a life policy would convert taxable growth into tax-free proceeds, which the rule does not permit.

Allowed 1035 Exchanges at a Glance

How a 1035 Exchange Works in Practice

The owner applies for the new contract and signs an exchange or assignment form. The new insurer then requests the funds directly from the old insurer, which transfers the cash value to the new contract.

The direct transfer is important. If the owner surrenders the old contract and receives a check, the transaction is a taxable surrender followed by a new purchase, even if the money is reinvested days later.

The owner, and for life insurance the insured, generally must stay the same. The cost basis, the premiums paid less any tax-free amounts already received, transfers to the new contract and determines how much of future withdrawals or payments will be taxable.

Worked Example One: An Annuity-to-Annuity Exchange

An investor bought a variable annuity years ago for $60,000. It is now worth $100,000, but it carries high fees, and she wants a lower-cost contract with better investment options.

Step one: identify the gain. The value of $100,000 minus the basis of $60,000 leaves an untaxed gain of $40,000. Step two: compare the two routes. If she surrenders the contract, the $40,000 gain is taxed as ordinary income, and if she is under 59½, a 10 percent additional tax of $4,000 may apply.

Step three: use a 1035 exchange instead. The full $100,000 moves directly to the new annuity, no tax is due, and her basis in the new contract remains $60,000. Step four: the $40,000 gain stays deferred until she withdraws money or annuitizes the new contract.

Worked Example Two: Receiving Cash in an Exchange

Suppose the same investor exchanges her $100,000 annuity but asks for $10,000 in cash, with $90,000 going into the new contract. Cash received in an otherwise tax-free exchange is called boot.

Step one: measure the gain: $40,000, as before. Step two: boot is taxable up to the amount of the gain, so the full $10,000 is taxed as ordinary income, because it is less than the $40,000 gain.

Step three: the remaining $30,000 of gain stays deferred inside the new contract. The lesson is that taking cash out during an exchange triggers tax on that cash to the extent of the gain, so most owners transfer the entire value.

Worked Example Three: Life Insurance to an Annuity

A 70-year-old no longer needs the death benefit of a whole life policy with a cash value of $150,000. He paid $90,000 in premiums and wants retirement income instead.

Step one: a life-to-annuity exchange is permitted, so the $150,000 can move into an annuity without tax. Step two: his basis of $90,000 carries over, and $60,000 of gain remains deferred.

Step three: when he annuitizes, each payment is split between a tax-free return of basis and taxable earnings. He has converted the policy into income while keeping the deferral, a common use of the rule in retirement planning. Our comparison of term vs whole life insurance explains how whole life cash value builds in the first place.

Partial Exchanges and Policy Loans

Owners do not always have to move the whole contract. IRS guidance allows a partial exchange, in which part of an annuity’s value moves into a new annuity tax-free and the rest stays in the original.

To prevent partial exchanges being used to withdraw gains cheaply, the guidance generally requires the owner to avoid withdrawals from either contract for 180 days after the transfer. A withdrawal within that window can cause the exchange to be treated as a taxable distribution.

Policy loans need care too. If a life policy with an outstanding loan is exchanged and the loan is paid off in the process, the amount of the loan relief is treated as boot and may be taxable, which can surprise an owner who expected the exchange to be entirely tax-free.

Study Insurance and Annuities With FRC

The 1035 exchange sits where taxation, insurance and suitability meet, which is why it appears on the exam. Our Series 65 course takes you through each rule, each permitted exchange and the conduct standards that apply when recommending a replacement.

Consider studying with FRC for every exam on your route. Explore our USA exam courses, from the SIE through the Series 7, Series 63 and Series 65.

To take advantage of the membership, explore FRC Professional Membership, which gives you a verified Digital Profile that shows employers your real-time course progress, together with the Video Resume. Current offers are on our membership deals page.

The Hidden Costs of an Exchange

A tax-free exchange is not a cost-free one. The new contract usually starts a fresh surrender charge schedule, which can tie up the money for another seven years or more, and the old contract may still charge a surrender fee on the way out.

For life insurance, a new policy restarts the contestability and suicide exclusion periods and may require new medical underwriting at an older age, which can raise the cost of cover. Valuable features in the old contract, such as a guaranteed interest rate or an enhanced death benefit, may be lost.

Our comparison of fixed vs variable annuities explains the surrender charges and fees that should be weighed in any annuity exchange. The question is always whether the client ends up better off after every cost is counted.

Regulation of Replacements

Because exchanges generate new commissions, regulators watch them closely. Under FINRA Rule 2330, a representative recommending a deferred variable annuity exchange must consider whether the customer would lose existing benefits, pay new surrender charges or face higher fees, and whether the customer has made another exchange within the previous 36 months.

State insurance law adds replacement rules. Most states require a replacement notice comparing the old and new contracts, and many give the buyer a free-look period to cancel the new contract.

Twisting, which means inducing a replacement through misrepresentation or an incomplete comparison, is prohibited under state insurance law. Our FINRA rules quick reference on duties and conflicts places Rule 2330 alongside the suitability and conduct rules that apply to every recommendation.

Ordinary Income, Not Capital Gains

Gains inside annuities and life insurance are taxed as ordinary income when they are finally withdrawn or surrendered, never at the lower long-term capital gains rates. That is true whether the contract held stocks, bonds or a fixed interest rate.

The difference matters when a client compares an annuity exchange with selling a taxable investment portfolio. Profits on shares held in an ordinary brokerage account for more than a year usually qualify for capital gains rates, and our capital gains calculator shows how those figures work for a taxable account.

A 1035 exchange keeps the deferral going, but it does not change the character of the eventual tax. Advisers often weigh this alongside estate planning goals, because annuity gains passed to heirs remain taxable income to them.

The Memory Aid

Remember this line: you can trade down the insurance ladder, but not back up it. Life insurance can become an annuity, but an annuity cannot become life insurance.

For the mechanics, remember direct, same, carry. The money moves directly between insurers, the owner stays the same, and the basis carries over.

For the costs, remember that tax-free does not mean free. New surrender charges, new underwriting and lost guarantees can outweigh the benefit of the switch.

Exam Traps to Avoid

The first trap is allowing an annuity to be exchanged for life insurance. That direction does not qualify under Section 1035.

The second trap is treating a surrender and repurchase as an exchange. If the owner takes the cash and buys a new contract, the gain is taxable, even if the money is reinvested immediately.

The third trap is thinking the gain disappears. A 1035 exchange defers tax, carrying the old basis into the new contract. The fourth trap is overlooking boot: cash received in the exchange is taxable to the extent of the gain.

A Client Scenario

A 58-year-old client owns a variable annuity bought 12 years ago, worth $250,000 with a basis of $150,000. It is past its surrender period but charges high annual fees, and a representative at another firm has suggested exchanging it for a new contract with a lifetime income rider.

The adviser reviews both contracts. The new annuity would start a seven-year surrender schedule, its rider fee would raise annual costs, and the old contract includes a death benefit guarantee worth more than the current value. A 1035 exchange would avoid tax on the $100,000 gain, but the client could lose a valuable guarantee and add years of surrender charges.

The adviser shows the client the full comparison, including the costs and the lost death benefit, and documents the analysis. Because her priority is income from age 65, a partial exchange that keeps the old contract’s death benefit on the remaining value may serve her better. The recommendation rests on her objectives, time horizon and risk tolerance, the heart of suitability.

The Dictionary as a Video Library

The FRC dictionary is a study tool, not just a glossary. Every entry pairs a written explanation with deep-dive video, on-page quizzes and interactive flash cards, so you can read a concept, watch it explained and test yourself in one place.

Rules are covered in the same depth, from FINRA Rule 2330 on variable annuity exchanges to the principles of insurance and risk management. Use the FRC dictionary to open every term in this article as its own explanation, video and quiz.

Practice Questions to Test Yourself

Question one: Can an annuity be exchanged tax-free for a life insurance policy under Section 1035? No. An annuity can be exchanged only for another annuity or a qualified long-term care contract.

Question two: A client surrenders an annuity, receives a check and buys a new annuity a week later. Is this a 1035 exchange? No. Because the client received the money, the surrender is taxable, and the gain is taxed as ordinary income.

Question three: What happens to the cost basis in a 1035 exchange? It carries over from the old contract to the new one, so the deferred gain remains taxable when money is eventually withdrawn.

Question four: An annuity worth $80,000 with a basis of $50,000 is exchanged, and the owner takes $5,000 in cash. How much is taxable? $5,000, because boot is taxable up to the amount of the $30,000 gain.

Question five: Which FINRA rule requires a representative to consider whether a customer has made another variable annuity exchange in the past 36 months? FINRA Rule 2330, which governs recommendations of deferred variable annuities.

Turn Planning Knowledge Into Career Evidence

Insurance and annuity planning skills are valued in wealth management, retirement planning and insurance-based advisory roles. FRC’s Digital Profile shows employers the courses you are actively studying and the progress you have earned through assessed learning, verified by FRC, and a QR code on your resume takes them straight to it.

The FRC Video Resume lets a hiring manager hear you before the interview. Explaining when an exchange helps a client and when it does not shows exactly the judgment advisory firms want.

Candidates returning to the exam should note that the wait after a third failure drops from 180 days to 60 days for exam windows opened on or after January 4, 2027, as explained in our article on the Series 65 retake rule change.

Related Questions

Continue with Fixed vs Variable Annuity for the contracts most often exchanged, and Term vs Whole Life Insurance for the policies that can be swapped into annuities.

For other Series 65 practice questions, read Rights of Accumulation vs Letter of Intent and Call Option vs Put Option.

Key Points to Retain

A 1035 exchange moves the value of a life insurance policy, endowment or annuity into another qualifying contract without immediate tax, with the old cost basis carrying over. Life insurance can be exchanged for life, endowment, annuity or long-term care contracts, but an annuity cannot be exchanged for life insurance.

The transfer should go directly between insurers with the same owner, and any cash received is taxable boot to the extent of the gain. Exchanges can bring new surrender charges and lost guarantees, and variable annuity exchanges fall under FINRA Rule 2330 and state replacement rules.

For the exam’s structure and requirements, see the Series 65 dictionary entry, and for the role the exam leads to, read our guide to what an investment advisor representative is.