Finance
Understanding the Application of MiFID II in the UK: Key Insights and Implications
Last updated: Jun 7, 2021 • 4min read
Globally Recognized Certifications
.png)
Finance
Last updated: Jun 7, 2021 • 4min read
The Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID II) is one of the most significant regulatory frameworks shaping the landscape of financial markets in the European Union (EU) and, post-Brexit, in the United Kingdom (UK). This updated directive, implemented in January 2018, builds upon the original MiFID (Markets in Financial Instruments Directive) that was introduced in 2007. MiFID II was created in response to the 2007-2008 global financial crisis, with the primary aim of addressing regulatory gaps that had emerged and enhancing market transparency, investor protection, and overall financial stability.
MiFID II is a broad and complex regulation with far-reaching implications for how financial services are provided, monitored, and regulated across a range of markets and financial instruments. The scope of MiFID II extends across asset classes, trading venues, investment firms, and market participants, all of whom must adhere to new standards of operation.
For the UK, MiFID II’s application has taken on added significance after Brexit. While the UK has retained much of the EU legislation through its Financial Services Act 2021, there are ongoing discussions regarding how UK regulations will diverge from EU rules moving forward.
This article will provide a thorough exploration of MiFID II, detailing its key provisions, its objectives, its practical application within the UK, and its role in reshaping financial market regulation. It will also examine the implications for firms, market participants, and investors, offering insights into compliance, governance, and the broader market structure under MiFID II.
MiFID II is designed to ensure the efficiency, transparency, and stability of financial markets. The key objectives of MiFID II are as follows:
MiFID II aims to improve transparency in financial markets to provide more accurate and timely information to market participants. Transparency is crucial in fostering fair and competitive markets and in preventing market manipulation.
Key aspects of market transparency include:
Pre-Trade Transparency: Financial instruments traded on regulated venues must have publicly available quotes and bid-ask spreads, which ensures that investors are able to access real-time price information before trading.
Post-Trade Transparency: MiFID II mandates that details of executed transactions, including price, volume, and time, must be published in a timely manner after the trade is completed. This enhances market oversight and promotes fair pricing.
A central aim of MiFID II is to ensure that investors are treated fairly and that their interests are protected. The directive introduces more stringent requirements for product governance, suitability, and disclosures.
Key provisions for investor protection include:
Suitability and Appropriateness Tests: Firms must assess whether financial products are suitable for retail investors based on their risk tolerance, investment objectives, and financial situation.
Clearer Information: MiFID II mandates that firms provide clear and comprehensive information about financial products, services, and fees to enable investors to make informed decisions.
Protection for Retail Clients: MiFID II introduces enhanced rules for the protection of retail investors, ensuring that firms act in their best interests, and providing mechanisms for redress in cases of mis-selling.
MiFID II also aims to strengthen the supervisory framework across EU and UK financial markets. The directive provides regulators with greater powers to enforce compliance and tackle breaches.
Key provisions to enhance supervision include:
Transaction Reporting: Firms must report detailed information on transactions to regulators to help detect and prevent market abuse, including insider trading and manipulation.
Market Abuse Prevention: The directive strengthens rules around market manipulation and insider trading. It also requires firms to monitor for any potentially abusive behaviour.
MiFID II is designed to encourage competition among market participants, thereby improving market efficiency. Additionally, the directive aims to mitigate systemic risks that could arise from concentrated trading or inadequate risk controls.
Provisions to promote competition and reduce risks include:
Trading Venue Rules: MiFID II applies stricter rules to regulated markets (RMs), multilateral trading facilities (MTFs), and systematic internalisers (SIs). These venues must provide more transparency and ensure fair access to trading.
Derivatives and Commodity Markets: The directive establishes stricter requirements for trading in derivative products, particularly through mandatory clearing and position limits, to reduce counterparty risk.
MiFID II seeks to keep pace with technological advancements in the financial industry, such as algorithmic and high-frequency trading (HFT). These new developments have introduced both opportunities and challenges to the market, prompting the need for regulatory attention.
Key provisions on technology include:
Algorithmic Trading: Firms engaging in algorithmic trading or HFT are subject to enhanced requirements, including the implementation of robust risk management systems and pre-trade checks.
Automated Execution Systems: Firms must ensure that their automated execution systems are designed to prevent market disruptions and ensure orderly trading.
MiFID II introduces a host of new provisions, some of which are quite detailed and technical in nature. Below is a summary of the key provisions that have the most significant impact on financial markets and participants.
MiFID II has a broad scope, applying to a wide range of financial instruments, markets, and activities. It affects investment firms, credit institutions, regulated markets, MTFs, and SIs.
Key areas of application include:
Financial Instruments: MiFID II regulates all financial instruments, including equities, bonds, derivatives, structured products, and commodities.
Trading Venues: The directive applies to a wide range of trading venues, including regulated markets (RMs), MTFs, and OTFs (Organised Trading Facilities). MiFID II also regulates systematic internalisers (SIs), which are firms that execute orders on their own account outside of public exchanges.
Non-EU Firms: MiFID II has extraterritorial application, meaning it applies to non-EU firms that provide services to EU or UK clients or operate in EU/UK markets.
MiFID II introduces stricter rules for the operation of trading venues. These rules aim to enhance transparency, ensure better liquidity, and promote fair competition. The key provisions for trading venues include:
Pre-Trade and Post-Trade Transparency: Trading venues are required to make more detailed information about orders and transactions publicly available. This includes requirements for firms to provide bid and ask prices before trades are executed and to disclose details of trades post-execution.
Multilateral Trading Facilities (MTFs): These venues provide a platform for multiple buyers and sellers to trade in a variety of instruments. MTFs must comply with a range of transparency and conduct requirements under MiFID II.
Systematic Internaliser (SI): Firms that act as systematic internalisers must comply with specific transparency requirements. SIs deal with orders internally and are subject to stringent reporting obligations.
The directive introduces enhanced requirements for best execution and investor protection, ensuring that financial firms act in the best interests of their clients.
Key provisions include:
Best Execution Obligation: Investment firms must take all sufficient steps to ensure that clients receive the best possible result when their orders are executed. This includes considering price, cost, speed, and likelihood of execution.
Suitability and Appropriateness: Firms must conduct suitability assessments for retail clients, ensuring that the products offered align with the client’s risk profile and financial situation. For more sophisticated clients, the appropriateness test ensures that products are suitable for their knowledge and experience.
MiFID II introduces stringent transaction reporting requirements to enhance market surveillance and detect potential market abuse.
Key reporting requirements include:
Transaction Reporting: Firms must report detailed transaction data, including the identity of clients, the instruments involved, and the terms of the transaction.
Trade Transparency: Firms must disclose post-trade information such as price, volume, and time to provide better insight into market activities.
MiFID II applies specific rules to commodity markets to enhance transparency and prevent excessive speculation.
Key provisions include:
Position Limits: MiFID II introduces position limits for commodity derivatives to prevent excessive speculation that could distort prices.
Mandatory Clearing: Derivatives that meet certain criteria must be centrally cleared to reduce counterparty risk and improve market stability.
The directive addresses the risks associated with algorithmic and high-frequency trading (HFT), which have become more prevalent in modern markets.
Key provisions include:
Risk Controls: Firms engaging in algorithmic trading must have effective risk controls in place to prevent disruptions to market order.
Market Making: Firms engaging in market-making activities must comply with enhanced transparency rules and ensure that they do not manipulate market prices through HFT strategies.
MiFID II establishes provisions for firms based outside the EU/UK to access EU/UK markets. Non-EU firms must meet certain equivalence requirements or be subject to additional regulatory oversight.
Post-Brexit, the UK has retained MiFID II within its regulatory framework, through the Financial Services Act 2021. However, there are notable differences in how MiFID II is applied in the UK compared to the EU. The UK has the freedom to amend its regulatory framework to reflect domestic market needs, while still ensuring a high level of market protection and transparency.
Key post-Brexit considerations include:
End of Passporting: UK firms no longer benefit from the EU passporting system, which allowed them to operate across the EU without needing separate licenses. UK firms must now apply for individual authorisations to operate in EU markets, and vice versa.
UK Regulatory Flexibility: The UK has the ability to adjust MiFID II requirements over time, providing flexibility to make regulatory changes that suit the UK’s financial services sector.
MiFID II is a comprehensive and detailed regulatory framework that has reshaped the European and UK financial markets. It aims to enhance transparency, protect investors, improve market efficiency, and reduce systemic risks. Its provisions cover a wide range of areas, including market structure, investor protection, transparency, trading venues, and transaction reporting.
For the UK, MiFID II represents an important part of the regulatory landscape, with post-Brexit modifications allowing for flexibility while maintaining core principles of market fairness and investor protection. As the regulatory environment evolves, firms and market participants must stay abreast of changes to ensure ongoing compliance and to navigate the complexities of the financial markets.
In sum, MiFID II is central to the creation of a more transparent, stable, and competitive financial market. Understanding its provisions and how they apply in both the EU and UK contexts is essential for firms, investors, and regulators alike. Through continued enforcement and adaptation, MiFID II will continue to guide the development of the financial services sector in the years to come.
Be the first to know about new class launches and announcements.
Financial writer and analyst Ron Finely shows you how to navigate financial markets, manage investments, and build wealth through strategic decision-making.
See why leading organizations rely on FRC for learning & development.
