.png)
Short selling is a strategy employed by investors to profit from a decline in the price of a financial asset, typically a stock. While it can offer lucrative returns, short selling also carries substantial risks and raises concerns regarding market manipulation, financial instability, and investor protection. To safeguard the financial system and ensure a level playing field for all market participants, the UK has established a robust regulatory framework governing short selling activities.
This article explores UK short selling regulations, detailing the key rules, risks, and reporting requirements that firms and traders must adhere to. It also highlights the importance of these regulations in maintaining market integrity and investor confidence.
Short selling involves selling a security that the seller does not own, with the intention of repurchasing it later at a lower price. The trader borrows the security from another party, usually a broker, and sells it on the open market. If the price of the security falls, the trader can buy it back at a lower price, return the borrowed shares, and pocket the difference.
For example, if a trader believes a company's stock price will decrease, they might:
Borrow 100 shares of that company from a broker.
Sell the 100 shares on the market at £50 per share, receiving £5,000.
Wait for the stock price to fall to £40 per share.
Repurchase the 100 shares for £4,000, return them to the broker, and make a profit of £1,000.
While the strategy can be profitable when the market declines, it is highly risky. If the market price of the security rises, the trader could incur significant losses, potentially unlimited, as there is no cap on how high the price of a security can rise.
The UK’s short selling regulations are primarily governed by the Short Selling (Regulation) (EU) No 236/2012 Regulation, which was introduced by the European Union to increase market transparency and reduce the potential for market manipulation. Following Brexit, the UK retained the provisions of this regulation under UK law through the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018. However, the UK government has the ability to make adjustments or amendments to these rules in the future.
Key regulations governing short selling in the UK include:
The Short Selling Regulation (EU) No 236/2012 is the cornerstone of short selling regulations in the UK, establishing rules designed to promote transparency, ensure the proper functioning of financial markets, and mitigate systemic risks. The regulation applies to both naked short selling and covered short selling.
Naked Short Selling: This occurs when a trader sells a security without borrowing it first, intending to profit from a price decline. Naked short selling is prohibited in the UK as it can lead to market manipulation and excessive volatility.
Covered Short Selling: This is the most common form of short selling, where traders borrow securities before selling them in the market. Covered short selling is permitted in the UK, but subject to strict rules and reporting requirements.
The FCA plays a key role in enforcing short selling regulations in the UK. As the regulatory body responsible for overseeing financial markets, the FCA ensures that short selling activities comply with transparency and disclosure requirements. It also has the authority to impose penalties and sanctions for non-compliance.
The Market Abuse Regulation (MAR), which is enforced by the FCA, covers market manipulation and insider trading. It prohibits activities that could distort financial markets, including actions related to short selling. Under MAR, short selling can be deemed illegal if it is part of a broader scheme to manipulate the price of a security or mislead investors.
One of the central elements of the UK’s short selling regulations is the requirement for transparency. Traders must disclose their short positions to regulators and, in some cases, to the public, depending on the size of the position.
Disclosures to the FCA: Under the Short Selling Regulation (EU) No 236/2012, traders must disclose their net short positions (i.e., the difference between the number of shares borrowed and the number of shares sold short) to the FCA when the position exceeds 0.2% of the issued share capital of a company. This disclosure must be made promptly, typically within one business day after reaching the 0.2% threshold.
Public Disclosure: If the short position exceeds 0.5% of the issued share capital of a listed company, the position must also be disclosed to the public. This requirement ensures that the market is informed of significant short positions that could influence market sentiment.
Daily Reporting for Large Short Positions: In addition to initial disclosures, traders holding large short positions may be required to update their positions daily, particularly if the position fluctuates significantly.
As mentioned earlier, naked short selling—where securities are sold without first borrowing them—is prohibited in the UK. This practice can cause serious harm to financial markets, as it can artificially inflate supply and contribute to excessive downward pressure on asset prices. Regulatory measures have been put in place to prevent market distortions caused by naked short selling, and the FCA has the power to take enforcement action against firms or individuals who engage in this practice.
In times of significant market volatility or financial crises, the FCA can impose temporary restrictions on short selling to protect market stability. For instance, the FCA has previously placed bans on short selling of stocks during periods of market distress, particularly in response to systemic risks or the threat of financial instability.
These temporary bans are designed to:
Prevent excessive volatility in times of crisis.
Protect vulnerable financial institutions from excessive speculative pressures.
Restore market confidence during periods of heightened uncertainty.
The ability of the FCA to impose such restrictions ensures that short selling does not exacerbate market downturns, while still maintaining a competitive and transparent market environment.
The UK has specific provisions regarding sovereign debt, including government bonds. Short selling of sovereign debt is subject to more stringent regulations due to the sensitivity of government bond markets and the potential systemic risks. Traders engaging in short selling of sovereign debt instruments are required to disclose their positions when they exceed specific thresholds, and the FCA monitors these positions closely.
While short selling can be a profitable strategy, it comes with significant risks, particularly for those who engage in it without fully understanding the potential consequences. Some of the primary risks of short selling include:
Unlike buying securities, where the maximum loss is limited to the amount invested, short selling exposes traders to unlimited losses. If the price of the asset rises significantly, the trader must repurchase the securities at a higher price to close their position, resulting in substantial losses. This creates a risk of margin calls, where traders may be forced to deposit additional funds to maintain their position.
Short selling can be used as part of market manipulation strategies, where traders aim to spread false information to drive down the price of an asset. The UK’s short selling regulations, including the Market Abuse Regulation (MAR), aim to prevent such practices by prohibiting any actions that might distort market prices or mislead other investors.
A short squeeze occurs when the price of a heavily shorted stock rises sharply, forcing short sellers to buy back shares to close their positions, which in turn drives the price even higher. This can lead to significant losses for short sellers who are caught in the squeeze.
If a stock is not actively traded or has low liquidity, it may be difficult for a short seller to cover their position. This can result in higher borrowing costs or even an inability to close the position, leading to potential financial distress.
Financial firms engaging in short selling must adhere to strict reporting and compliance requirements to ensure transparency and prevent market manipulation. In addition to the FCA's reporting obligations, firms must:
Maintain records of all short selling transactions.
Report significant short positions in line with the 0.2% and 0.5% disclosure thresholds.
Submit detailed records and transaction reports to regulators, especially when dealing with large volumes of short-selling activity.
Failure to comply with reporting requirements can result in penalties, fines, or sanctions from the FCA, as well as reputational damage to the financial firm involved.
Short selling plays a crucial role in the UK’s financial markets, allowing investors to express views on the price direction of stocks and other assets. However, due to its potential risks, it is tightly regulated to ensure that it does not undermine market stability or investor confidence.
The UK’s short selling regulations strike a balance between allowing investors to use short selling as a legitimate strategy while preventing abuse and protecting market integrity. By enforcing strict reporting requirements, prohibiting naked short selling, and giving the FCA powers to act in times of market instability, these regulations aim to foster a transparent, fair, and stable trading environment for all participants.
As market conditions evolve, financial firms and traders must stay informed of any changes to short selling regulations to ensure ongoing compliance and mitigate the associated risks.
Be the first to know about new class launches and announcements.
Financial writer and analyst Ron Finely shows you how to navigate financial markets, manage investments, and build wealth through strategic decision-making.
See why leading organizations rely on FRC for learning & development.
